Fishing · 0:30
An Honest Fish Story: Guessing a Flathead Catfish's Weight

How much does a flathead catfish weigh? It depends on who is telling the story. In this 30-second clip the first guess is 30 to 35 pounds, maybe. By the end it is about 20 pounds, 18 to 20, and that honest correction is the best part.
He's small, but he'd probably go about 30-35 pounds maybe.
Every fisherman knows the temptation
Fish grow every time the story is told. A 20-pound flathead becomes 30 by Sunday and 40 by Christmas. This clip goes the other direction: a big first guess, then an honest look, then a smaller number.
It is a small thing, but small things are where honesty lives. Scripture says a false balance is an abomination to the Lord, but a just weight is His delight.
About 20 pounds, 18-20 pounds.
Estimating a flathead's weight
Without a scale, fishermen estimate by length and girth. A long fish can still be lean, and it is easy to overshoot while the fish is still in the water. Here the number comes down once the fish is in hand.
- Guess high while it is fighting
- Look again when it is in hand
- Tell the truth about the number
Read the full transcript
Machine transcript of the captions. Words in brackets could not be heard clearly.
0:00He ain't a big one. He's small, but he'd probably go about 30-35 pounds maybe. Look at that dude. [unclear] he was hooked. I'll bring him up for you. There you go. About 20 pounds, 18-20 pounds.
Questions people ask
- How much did this catfish weigh?
- The first guess was 30 to 35 pounds. The final estimate was about 20 pounds, 18 to 20.
- How do you estimate a catfish's weight without a scale?
- Fishermen use length and girth. Estimates made while the fish is fighting tend to run high, so look again once it is in hand.
Get involved
Tell the true story.
Share this one with your fishing buddy, and support the work Don and Patti do in Ore City.



